DETROIT TIGER FANS!

A place for Detroit Tiger Fans to come together for a bit of fun
HomeHome  ­CalendarCalendar  ­FAQFAQ  ­SearchSearch  ­RegisterRegister  ­MemberlistMemberlist  ­UsergroupsUsergroups  ­Log inLog in  
Please log in and join in the fun of game day threads (GDT) and in overall Tigers chat.
Post new topic   Reply to topicShare | 
 

 Lord of the Flies (1963)

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
AuthorMessage
catbox_9
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 22244
Age: 22
Location: Paso Robles, California
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Justin Verlander
Reputation: 17
Registration date: 2007-10-05

PostSubject: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Fri Mar 06, 2009 11:09 pm

Lord of the Flies is based on the famous novel of the same name. Unlike most novel-based movies, I have actually read this novel. Like the book, this film tells the story of a group of boys aged 6-12 on an uninhabited island during World War 2. Their plane has crashed and they are the only survivors. They attempt to build a society while they await their rescue but the society quickly falls apart. While mostly faithful to the book, this plot played out rather dully while it was vastly superior in the novel.

The film stars a group of people who were not, and still are not, famous. Generally I don't care for children as actors. This film is no exception. The children do a decent enough job, but none of them were even close to award-worthy.

My main problem with this film is the deviations from the novel. While it is expected that a film will deviate from a novel some, the deviations in here seem quite odd. Simon, one of the most important characters in the novel, is fairly irrelevant in this film. His encounter with the Lord of the Flies, perhaps the most important scene in the book, is mostly omitted from the film. To a viewer who is unfamiliar with the book, this film offers no reason as to why it is titled Lord of the Flies whereas the book makes that quite clear. In addition, Roger, another important character in the book, is barely mentioned in this film. The film is a little less violent than the book largely due to the fact Roger is barely involved in this film. There are other notable omissions or changes, but I will not mention any others.

This film goes to show that unless the film is quite famous, films based on famous literature don't generally work. Some of the most important pieces of literature in history (most notably the over 400-year-old Don Quixote) have never been given a decent film adaptation. This film is yet another example of a poor attempt to transform a well-regarded book into a movie. It failed. I would suggest that fans of the book skip this and I would strongly discourage anyone not familiar with the book from even considering watching this film.

42/100
F

_________________
Coming Soon: A better signature!
Back to top Go down
View user profile
bobrob2004
DTF1 MODERATOR
Detroit Tiger

DTF1 MODERATOR Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 10632
Age: 24
Location: Warren, MI
Reputation: 12
Registration date: 2007-10-05

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Sat Mar 07, 2009 11:07 am

They made a movie out of this? I read the book in high school.

_________________
bow Z. Miner
Back to top Go down
View user profile
gs78
Detroit Tiger
Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 27673
Age: 31
Location: Trashy Park Michigan
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Dontrelle Willis, Brandon Inge, Maggs, Verlander, Granderson, Pudge and Todd Jones
Reputation: 9
Registration date: 2007-10-06

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Sat Mar 07, 2009 11:39 am

I read the book in school


And seen the movie



The book gets a 67

The movie a 37
Back to top Go down
View user profile
gs78
Detroit Tiger
Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 27673
Age: 31
Location: Trashy Park Michigan
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Dontrelle Willis, Brandon Inge, Maggs, Verlander, Granderson, Pudge and Todd Jones
Reputation: 9
Registration date: 2007-10-06

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Sat Mar 07, 2009 11:40 am

I might have enjoyed the book more if I didn't have to do a paper on it
Back to top Go down
View user profile
gs78
Detroit Tiger
Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 27673
Age: 31
Location: Trashy Park Michigan
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Dontrelle Willis, Brandon Inge, Maggs, Verlander, Granderson, Pudge and Todd Jones
Reputation: 9
Registration date: 2007-10-06

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Sat Mar 07, 2009 11:40 am

I got something like a C-
Back to top Go down
View user profile
catbox_9
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 22244
Age: 22
Location: Paso Robles, California
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Justin Verlander
Reputation: 17
Registration date: 2007-10-05

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Sat Mar 07, 2009 6:31 pm

bobrob2004 wrote:
They made a movie out of this? I read the book in high school.


There's a newer movie, too (from 1990ish).

We didn't read it in high school. I read it last week.

_________________
Coming Soon: A better signature!
Back to top Go down
View user profile
catbox_9
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 22244
Age: 22
Location: Paso Robles, California
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Justin Verlander
Reputation: 17
Registration date: 2007-10-05

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Sat Mar 07, 2009 6:35 pm

gs78 wrote:
I read the book in school


And seen the movie



The book gets a 67

The movie a 37


Score logged. I'd give the book more like an 85. I didn't write a paper on it though so that helps.

Reading should never be forced - it always sucks that way.

_________________
Coming Soon: A better signature!
Back to top Go down
View user profile
gs78
Detroit Tiger
Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 27673
Age: 31
Location: Trashy Park Michigan
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Dontrelle Willis, Brandon Inge, Maggs, Verlander, Granderson, Pudge and Todd Jones
Reputation: 9
Registration date: 2007-10-06

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Tue Mar 10, 2009 2:19 pm

catbox_9 wrote:
gs78 wrote:
I read the book in school


And seen the movie



The book gets a 67

The movie a 37


Score logged. I'd give the book more like an 85. I didn't write a paper on it though so that helps.

Reading should never be forced - it always sucks that way.




Exactly


I don't think there is a single book that I was forced to do a report on in high school or college that is one my bookshelf now
Back to top Go down
View user profile
catbox_9
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger
DTF1 ADMINISTRATOR Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 22244
Age: 22
Location: Paso Robles, California
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Justin Verlander
Reputation: 17
Registration date: 2007-10-05

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Tue Mar 10, 2009 6:07 pm

gs78 wrote:
catbox_9 wrote:
gs78 wrote:
I read the book in school


And seen the movie



The book gets a 67

The movie a 37


Score logged. I'd give the book more like an 85. I didn't write a paper on it though so that helps.

Reading should never be forced - it always sucks that way.




Exactly


I don't think there is a single book that I was forced to do a report on in high school or college that is one my bookshelf now


Remember how bad Shakespeare was in high school? Remember how bad it still is?

_________________
Coming Soon: A better signature!
Back to top Go down
View user profile
bobrob2004
DTF1 MODERATOR
Detroit Tiger

DTF1 MODERATOR Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 10632
Age: 24
Location: Warren, MI
Reputation: 12
Registration date: 2007-10-05

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Wed Mar 11, 2009 5:21 am

catbox_9 wrote:
gs78 wrote:
catbox_9 wrote:
gs78 wrote:
I read the book in school


And seen the movie



The book gets a 67

The movie a 37


Score logged. I'd give the book more like an 85. I didn't write a paper on it though so that helps.

Reading should never be forced - it always sucks that way.




Exactly


I don't think there is a single book that I was forced to do a report on in high school or college that is one my bookshelf now


Remember how bad Shakespeare was in high school? Remember how bad it still is?


Nod

_________________
bow Z. Miner
Back to top Go down
View user profile
gs78
Detroit Tiger
Detroit Tiger


Male
Number of posts: 27673
Age: 31
Location: Trashy Park Michigan
Favorite Current Tiger(s): Dontrelle Willis, Brandon Inge, Maggs, Verlander, Granderson, Pudge and Todd Jones
Reputation: 9
Registration date: 2007-10-06

PostSubject: Re: Lord of the Flies (1963)   Wed Mar 11, 2009 2:50 pm

catbox_9 wrote:
gs78 wrote:
catbox_9 wrote:
gs78 wrote:
I read the book in school


And seen the movie



The book gets a 67

The movie a 37


Score logged. I'd give the book more like an 85. I didn't write a paper on it though so that helps.

Reading should never be forced - it always sucks that way.




Exactly


I don't think there is a single book that I was forced to do a report on in high school or college that is one my bookshelf now


Remember how bad Shakespeare was in high school? Remember how bad it still is?



Nice to know some things stay the same
Back to top Go down
View user profile
 

Lord of the Flies (1963)

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions of this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
DETROIT TIGER FANS! :: Off Topic :: Movies-
Post new topic   Reply to topic